Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Human Rights
Obama’s Hesitant Embrace of Human Rights
Obama’s Hesitant Embrace of Human Rights
As one would expect from so eloquent a leader, US President Barack Obama has brought about a marked improvement in presidential rhetoric on human rights in comparison with his predecessor.
Monday, March 8,2010 23:37
by Kenneth Roth Human Rights Watch


In a series of speeches around the world, carefully tailored for each audience, the president has set forth a compelling vision, emphasising that respect for human rights is not only right but also broadly beneficial for the United States and the world. The challenge facing his administration is translating that rhetoric into policy and practice.

In Cairo, for example, President Obama stressed the importance of democracy. Unlike President George W. Bush, who stopped promoting democracy in the Middle East when Hamas won elections in the Palestinian territories and the Muslim Brotherhood fared better than expected in Egyptian parliamentary elections, Obama suggested that he would accept the results of fair elections no matter who won. But disappointingly, he has done little to push US-allied autocrats in the region, such as President Hosni Mubarak of Egypt and the Saudi royal family, in a more democratic direction.

In Africa, President Bill Clinton once lionised such “new African leaders” as President Paul Kagame of Rwanda and Prime Minister Meles Zenawi of Ethiopia, each of whom has since turned in a disturbingly authoritarian direction. Obama implicitly repudiated that approach during a speech in Accra, when he said that Africa does not need “strong men” but “strong institutions,” such as honest police forces, powerful parliaments and independent journalists. Yet that insight has not yielded sustained pressure on either Kagame or Zenawi to reverse course.

The Russian government has sought to impede critical human rights reporting by imposing burdensome regulatory requirements. Obama responded by meeting with civil society leaders and stressing in a Moscow speech that US civil society, by questioning his policies, made him govern better. Yet he has not put serious pressure on Russia to bring to justice those people behind the murder epidemic of activists and journalists — arguably the most serious threat to Russian civil society today.

President Obama touched on the right points about the importance of respecting human rights when visiting China, but he undermined his message by failing to meet beforehand with the Dalai Lama and by flubbing his response to a question about the Chinese Internet firewall, by suggesting that censorship might represent a different “tradition” rather than an obvious violation of freedom of expression.

Secretary of State Hillary Clinton did not help matters when she said earlier that human rights “can’t interfere” with otherwa. Predictably, Obama got little if anything in human rights terms from his visit to China. Indeed, a short time later, China imposed one of the lengthiest prison terms in a long time on a leading human rights activist.

Even on counterterrorism — the area where Obama’s policies appeared at first to be farthest from Bush’s — the results are less than had been hoped. Obama ordered the CIA to abide by the military’s stricter rules for interrogation and shut the secret detention facilities where terrorism suspects “disappeared” and were tortured, but he has refused to investigate — let alone prosecute — the senior officials who ordered torture or the government lawyers who provided thin legal justifications for it. It is not enough for a president to observe the law if he does not also defend the law by prosecuting those responsible for blatant breaches.

Similarly, Obama said he would close the Guant?namo Bay prison, but it seems he may have meant only the physical facility, not the policies that it represents; he proposes to continue trying some suspects in military commissions that are slightly improved from those that Bush supported, but still substandard. In addition, the Obama administration has now indicated that some 47 suspects will continue to be subject to long-term detention without trial.

Suspects held unjustly in Guant?namo or tried in military commissions are worth far more to terrorist recruiters than suspects who are released. It would be better to try them in regular federal courts, which have proved fully capable of handling these types of cases, than military commissions. Regular trials are most likely to produce results, the fairness of which no one could contest. President Obama recognises the importance of redeeming America’s reputation on human rights after the dark Bush years. But it will take more than impressive rhetoric to succeed. Words must be followed by deeds.



tags: Obama / Bush / Parliamentary Elections / CIA / Guantanamo / Hamas / Mubarak / Bill Clinton / Kagame / Zenawi / Russian Government / Dalai Lama / Hillary Clinton / US Military / Obama Administration /
Posted in Human Rights , Obama  
Related Articles
Does Obama Have His Own Freedom Agenda Or Not?
Egyptian human rights leaders meet Obama
Obama, Muslims & Islamism
Poll shows Obama making in roads in Arab world
BREAKING NEWS: New Obama Envoy Has History Of Engagement With U.S. Muslim Brotherhood
Members of U.S. Congress Ask President Obama to End the Blockade of Gaza
Is Obama a Peacemaker or a Warmonger?
Obama's Budget Ducks Pentagon Cuts
Obama Administration Unsupportive of Middle East Democracy?
Obama Ignores Key Afghan Warning
USF Student questions Obama on human rights in the Middle East
NATO troops kill Afghan cleric, officials say
Obama and the Middle East: One Year On, A New Beginning?
Obama and the Arab World: The Honeymoon Is Really Over Now
Complaint Filed Against Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld et al
Obama staffer wants ‘cognitive infiltration’ of 9/11 conspiracy groups
How to Revive Obama's Middle East Policy? Some Responses.
Two 'Resolutions' for Obama in 2010
'Neocon-ing' Obama
Break the CIA in Two
People of the decade: From Osama to Obama
Obama's Weak Report Card on the CIA
International Artists unite in an initiative to end illegal US detentions in Guantanamo Bay.
Is Obama Continuing the Bush/Cheney Assassination Program?
Arab Opinion: Bush Bad, Obama Good
US Must Prosecute Bush Torture Memo Lawyers: UN Torture Envoy
What Bush Hath Wrought in the Middle East
Six Years in Guantanamo
Guantanamo as a Symbol
UN rights envoy suspects CIA of Guantanamo torture
A Call for the investigation about the violent actions during Egyptian parliamentary elections
Guantanamo Deaths, Where Does the Truth Lie?