Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Activites
Egypt violates international law by imprisoning blogger, says UN body
Egypt violates international law by imprisoning blogger, says UN body
Blogger Karim Amer’s imprisonment is a violation of international law, United Nations experts have concluded
Wednesday, March 25,2009 03:17
by Sarah Carr DailyStarEgypt.com

Blogger Karim Amer’s imprisonment is a violation of international law, United Nations experts have concluded.

Amnesty International released a statement Monday sent to it by the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention, a special procedure body of the UN’s Human Rights Council.

The Working Group concludes that Amer’s deprivation of liberty constitutes arbitrary detention because the blogger was “condemned for his online criticism and for the exercise of his right to freedom of opinion and expression.”

“The decision of the Working Group is a welcome warning to the Egyptian authorities not to hide behind defamation of religion or insults to heads of state as a way to curb freedom of expression,” Amnesty International says in its statement.

In February 2007 Amer received a four-year imprisonment sentence after being convicted of charges including defaming the Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak and inciting hatred of Islam.

Amer’s imprisonment for statements made online is the first time Egypt has jailed a blogger. The Working Group was notified about the case in a communication sent to it in 2007.

Amer’s lawyers have alleged on several occasions that their client has been subject to mistreatment inside prison.

These accusations — including that Amer was on one occasion kept in solitary confinement for 65 days, and that in October 2007 he was punched and kicked by a prison guard and a prisoner acting under the supervision of a prison investigations officer — are denied by the Egyptian government in a response sent to the Working Group.

The government rejects suggestions that the charge of defaming the President on which Amer was convicted violates international law, and distinguishes between “responsible and proper media and newspaper coverage based on facts and information” and “use of the right to expression in order to harm the honor and reputation of other[s]”.

The government also invokes the idea of “special duties and responsibilities in the exercise of freedom of expression” to defend Amer"s conviction of insulting Islam. It suggests that the restrictions are necessary to “protect freedom of belief and avoid inciting hatred and discrimination against a group of people”.

Both arguments are rejected by the Working Group which says that the duty under international law to protect individuals against attacks on their honor and reputation does not mean that violation of this tenet should be deemed a criminal offence, nor that it should be punished by a penal sanction.

A penal sanction is “particularly inappropriate”, where the victim of the alleged defamation is a public figure because, “public officials should tolerate more criticism than private individuals,” the Working Groups says.

“Such criminal laws have an inhibiting effect on the exercise of the right to freedom of opinion and expression,” the Working Group statement reads.

“Imprisonment terms for bloggers convicted of defaming or insulting state authorities is disproportionate and seriously affects freedom of opinion and expression.”

The UN body also dismisses Egypt"s contention that limitations on freedom of expression are necessary to protect freedom of belief.

“There is no contradiction between freedom of opinion and freedom of religion. They are mutually reinforcing … Certain beliefs cannot limit the right of the persons with other beliefs or different opinions to express their ideas and views,” the Working Group statement reads.

“Defamation of religions may offend people and hurt their feelings but it does not directly result in a violation of the right to freedom of religion.”

Egypt, whose term at the UN Human Rights Council expires next year, will have its human rights record assessed in 2010 under the Universal Periodic Review mechanism.

The review, carried out by Human Rights Council member states, is based in part on a compilation of UN information including the Working Group decision.

Hassiba Hadj Sahraoui, deputy director of the Middle East and North Africa program at Amnesty International, suggests that the decision may have implications for this review.

“As Egypt is coming up for review before the Human Rights Council and will have its record examined by fellow states, can Egypt afford to disregard the decisions of the human rights experts of the very same body examining its record?” Hadj Sahraoui told Daily News Egypt.

“This decision on Amer is also key as Egypt has been very active in promoting a resolution on defamation of religions, and trying to inject language on defamation of religion in the resolution on freedom of expression. These initiatives were simply ways to further limit freedom of expression,” she continued.

“The Working Group decision is so unequivocal that it would be hard for Egypt to continue with its undermining tactics at the Human Rights Council.

We also hope that in line with the findings Egypt will amend its legislation to decriminalize defamation.”

Posted in Activites , Other Blogs , Human Rights  
Related Articles
Egypt must halt campaign against bloggers
Egypt: Detained blogger Ahmed Abou Doma is at risk of torture
Moroccan anti-corruption journalist & blogger arrested Journalist should be questioned not detained
Egyptian Opposition Turns Attention to Jailed Blogger
Blogger Adel Started an Open Strike
Endless Escalation Between Egyptian Bloggers, Regime
Egyptian blogger held incommunicado is at risk of torture
Blogger Freedom in Egypt
Freed Egyptian protester describes ordeal, but fate of seized blogger is unknown
Phillip Rizk...Blogger Behind Bars for Gaza
Blogger Adel Threatens with Strike on Bad Detention Conditions
Egyptian Bloggers and Journalists in the Hot Seat
Egypt Police Arrest Three Participants in Gaza Relief Convoy, Including Blogger
Missing Blogger Detained by Interior Ministry Decision
Communication Accuses Interior Ministry Of Kidnapping Blogger Mohamed Adel
Egypt: one blogger disappeared and another still in custody despite court order
Protest Against Blogger’s Disappearance, Extending Detention of Another
Blogger Disappears in Mysterious Circumstances
Fayyoum Prosecution Decides To Release Blogger Khairi
Blogger Mohamed Khairi To Be Referred Tomorrow
Blogger Mohamed Khairi Arrested for the Second Time
Kareem Amer: two years awaiting justice
Blogger Mamdouh El Monayyar Released After Seven- Month Detention
Bloggers bucking the Brotherhood in Egypt
Faiyum Bloggers Violated At The Prison
Blogger Abdul Tawwab Abducted From Faiyum
ANHRI: Egyptian Internet Bloggers Vulnerable To Arrest & Persecution
An Egyptian woman blogger has received an international prize
Bloggers and the Brotherhood
Moroccan Appeals Court Acquits Blogger Mohamed Al Rajhi
Sit-in For Releasing Blogger Before Prosecutor General Office
In One Session, Without Defense or Lawyers The Sentence of the Moroccan Blogger, Mohamed Elrraji...
Egypt bloggers take on U.S. elections
The Prosecution of the First Moroccan Blogger
April 6 Youth Protests to Have a Blogger Released
Family of MB Blogger Demands His Release
Security Guards harass Karim Amer in Borg El-Arab Prison
Police Assaults A Woman In A Rally Against Blogger Detention
Petition For Prosecutor General To Release Blogger Refaat
The State Security Arrest a Blogger under the State of Emergency Law
Egyptian blogger Mohamed Refaat is released
MP Al-Husseini: Gov’t Still Detains Al-Monayar, MB Blogger
Karim Amer Tortured in Borg Alarab prison Demands to the Prosecutor-General to investigate the issue
Blogger Karim Amer Tortured in Burj Al-Arab Prison
MB op-ed defends Kareem Amer
Kareem Amer and Abdul-Moneim Mahmoud
Petition For Release Of Bloggers Kareem Amer And Abdul-Moneim Mahmud
Revocation of Karim Amer’s verdict Last chance for justice